Wednesday, July 23, 2014

New study reveals that more than half of the people executed in this country are mentally ill. Oh my god!

Courtesy of the Washington Post:  

A new study by Robert J. Smith, Sophie Cull and Zoë Robinson, published in Hastings Law Journal, of the social histories of 100 people executed during 2012 and 2013 showed that the vast majority of executed offenders suffered from one or more significant cognitive and behavioral deficits. 

One-third of the offenders had intellectual disabilities, borderline intellectual function or traumatic brain injuries, a similarly debilitating impairment. For example, the Texas Department of Corrections determined that Elroy Chester had an IQ of 69. He attended special education classes throughout school and never functioned at a higher level than third grade. The state had previously enrolled Chester into its Mentally Retarded Offenders Program. Despite these findings, Texas executed him on June 12, 2013. 

More than half of the 100 had a severe mental illness such as schizophrenia, post-traumatic stress disorder or psychosis. For example, for more than 40 years, Florida’s own psychiatrists found that John Ferguson suffered from severe mental illness. Ferguson had a fixed delusion that he was the “Prince of God” who could not be killed and would rise up after his execution and fight alongside Jesus to save the United States from a communist plot. When Ferguson was executed on Aug. 5, 2013, his last words were: “I just want everyone to know that I am the Prince of God and I will rise again.”

On Ferguson's belief that he was the "Prince of God," the Florida court stated that his delusions were "normal Christian beliefs." Which is very troubling but may be the result of how many Christians have been acting lately.

I am shocked by these statistics, even though I have long been aware that many mentally ill people are sent to prison as criminals, when instead they should be sent to psychiatric hospitals as patients.

I work this population all of the time and I can tell you that their behaviors can be incredibly challenging, especially those who are schizophrenic of have psychotic episodes.

However if they receive the care they need, and the medications they require, they can sometimes live reasonably happy and productive lives.

Throwing them into a cage and ultimately killing them for something they may have had no, or little, ability to control is inhumane and a travesty of justice.

But the problem is that this country has little problem shoveling piles of money into the prison system to warehouse the mentally ill, or execute them, yet balks at the money needed to prevent them from becoming criminals and providing the support they will need for their entire lives to enjoy the freedom that is their birthright as Americans.

16 comments:

  1. Anonymous4:25 AM

    Where do you propose these mentally ill people be put? There are no mental hospitals for them. Weren't the mental hospitals closed down under Reagan? Weren't smaller community based hospitals supposed to be built instead of large institutions? If you have a mentally ill teenager, there are no services for them unless your insurance pays for a few weeks of residential services. Until the mental health system is totally overhauled and our attitudes towards the mentally Ill change, the prisons will still be our warehouses for those with mental illness.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous4:56 AM

      Very true. The care for the mentally ill in this country is practically non-existent. VA State Sen. Creigh Deeds son was mentally ill. Stabbed the Sen. and then shot himself. Deeds had money, influence and tried to get his son the help he needed, and it went very wrong. Imagine how the rest of us with a lot less money, political weight, and resources must deal with. The options are just not there. This countries' priorities are very messed up.

      Delete
    2. Anonymous5:07 AM

      YEP, you can thank Saint Reagan!

      Delete
    3. Anonymous5:18 AM

      While the mental health system in this country is in desperate need of fixing, the solution for these people is certainly not death row. There are probably many cases in which mentally ill people are arrested, tried and convicted for crimes they simply did not commit but were powerless to defend themselves adequately.
      Beaglemom

      Delete
  2. Anonymous4:27 AM

    "She said she was driving home from an early-morning bikram hot yoga workout in Anchorage."
    This can be confirmed, right?

    ReplyDelete
  3. sewnup4:47 AM

    I agree totally with the poster above. Sweet Ronnie's complete disregard for the problems of mental illness and the mentally ill (especially hard to understand since a number of people in his life were mentally ill) has given us not only prisons full of people who don't belong there but schools struggling to deal with students they're not equipped to understand. Then there are the ever-increasing loads that communities are carrying with homelessness, etc--and all without the funding promised at the time of deinstitutionalization.. Sweet Ronnie left a legacy, all right, and it ain't sweet.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anonymous5:14 AM

    Off Topic:
    Sarah caught speeding last week.
    http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/07/22/sarah-palin-speeding-ticket_n_5611883.html

    Please delete this comment.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Anonymous6:52 AM

    I'm not surprised. My stepson is schizophrenic and murdered someone brutally. We tried and tried and tried to get help for him unsuccessfully for years. I always knew he would murder someone and he did. They tried to put him on trial, but that ended up in a mistrial because he truly is mentally incompetent to stand trial and he waits in a mental hospital to be made competent to stand trial again. I highly doubt that will ever happen. He remains delusional despite treatment for several years. Our society has not treated the mentally ill as it should have thanks to all the cuts made to save money. In fact, it costs the taxpayers a lot more money to constantly put the mentally ill in jail in a revolving door system. Too bad the right wing is so heartless unless it hits their own family. Untreated mental illness costs society a lot of money and a lot of serious problems. What a shame.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous7:40 AM

      I am so sorry for your nightmare.

      Delete
  6. Anonymous7:01 AM

    Seeing that piture makes me cry. This is too sad.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Anonymous7:43 AM

    Thank you for this important post. Yes, there is untold wealth to be bestowed on prisons-for-hire. Not so much to treat or at least humanely house (because some cannot be successfully treated) the dangerously mentally ill.

    And why? Every single social ill this country suffers from can be traced to the fact that the merciless, judgmental, wedded to ignorance, use Bible to justify anything heinous, Puritans came here and their descendants eventually took everything over.

    ReplyDelete
  8. hedgewytch9:01 AM

    This and the very large numbers of innocent people who end up on death row, the amount of $ we spend on housing people on death row, and then attempting to execute them (sometimes horrifically) is why I am against the Death Penalty.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Anita Winecooler5:47 PM

    I'm surprised the numbers are that high, but not shocked at all. We had a cousin who was mentally ill, his parents did the best they could, he was misdiagnosed early, the school system in his small town just pushed him from grade to grade till he graduated. His parents were well off and STILL there was no help for him. He had a rare form of Epilepsy combined with Paranoid Schitzophrenia.... he wouldn't hurt a fly, yet he was brave enough to end his suffering through suicide.
    Prison is no place for the mentally ill. I understand the victim's family need for "justice", but when the person is mentally ill, and no help is available for the average family, once they reach the age of majority, little, if anything can be done.
    Thank You for bringing this to everyone's attention, perhaps we'll get reform or find a way to help people cope.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Anonymous9:05 PM

    I read an article years ago, by a young woman whose brother was killed by someone with mental illness. This young lady was so intrigued by the complexities of the brain, forgave the killer, whom she didn't "blame" and went on to get an education to be a mental health counselor.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Anonymous9:05 PM

    This travesty reminds me of the "witch hunts" of the past. Things haven't changed much, have they?

    ReplyDelete
  12. You can leave all of this at the feet of St. Reagan.

    Ronnie balanced the California budget but eliminated all suport and resources for the mentally ill. Basically fired the staff, closed the doors and shoved people out on the street to fend for themselves.

    They're still there.

    ReplyDelete

Don't feed the trolls!
It just goes directly to their thighs.